Brain Imaging Center & Art Dept.

Brain Imaging Center & Art Dept.

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

the light/tunnel ratio



"As minimalist artists have taught us, form is never pure; it can always stimulate associations." (Freedman, p 42)


"In Mr. Serra’s case you can also call it democratic art because it sticks to pure form that requires no previous expertise to grasp." (Kimmelman's New York Times review of MoMA's Serra retrospective)


First of all (or rather, second of all--see how I snuck those two quotations up there to set up a dichotomy for my arguments before I even began to address the reader directly?), let me apologize because I never got around to finishing the argument that I'd worked up in my previous post.  What it boiled down to is pretty neatly captured by the jotted note that I made while reading those first two chapters: "Freedman's approach, with its broad narrative and exhaustive citations, strives for subjectivity, while her tone works against it," the overall effect of which serves to make her argument less coherent and her history less convincing.  I suspect that her goal is to provide us with a catalog of the ideas that have influenced her thinking, some of which she has assimilated or built on and some of which she has reacted against.  This approach makes sense if she aligns herself with post-structuralist theory (and, to my mind, the quote from her that I used up top confirms that alignment), but it comes off as a history with a not-so-well-hidden argument as a subtext.  Her book would gain substantial clarity, credibility, and readability if she would take the first sentence of chapter four (which comes, tellingly, with a citation from Eisner attached) to heart and foreground her own sensibilities, tell some stories, and generally let the reader see how she evolved into the voice that is presently speaking to them through her book instead of burying her head in the forest of erudition and Lacanian quadruple speak.


My own intention in taking so very long to work my way up to that conclusion in that past post was to provide an example of the kind of writing that I prefer: writing that demonstrates a sense of personhood and brings the reader along a path with definite landmarks that can be retraced like bread crumbs.  Eisner, I feel, represents this type of writing as well.  When I finish reading Eisner, I can remember various descriptions that he's incorporated into the chapter and, whether I agree with him or not, I have a pretty strong sense that I've followed the thrust of his argument.  By contrast, when I finish reading a chapter of Freedman, I have to look back at the notes I've made in the margins and do my darnedest to form a picture of the chapter as a whole--and if I don't do this, I leave the reading almost completely blank.

Ironically (or does it become meta-irony, since irony is one of the favorite languages of the type of "post-Pop Surrealism" that Serra dismisses and that Freedman would adamantly defend?), the aesthetic choices that Freedman has made as a writer do not follow the standards that she advocates for both art and learning.  Instead of creating a context-rich environment in which metacognitively-activated learning will be scaffolded by the materials that she presents, she has created a hermetic world in which her research and thought is presented unmediated by familiar (or uncanny) structures.  And just as ironically, that great stalwart structuralist, Richard Serra, whose works appeals unmediated to each and every viewer regardless the wealth of their "imagic stores," once made the comment that "Art is not democratic."

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

TLC 8740 post in progress

First of all, it looks like the link that I posted to Laurie Anderson's Only An Expert has gone kaput, so here's another:

Only An Expert

And while we're cruising YouTube, how 'bout this one too:

The Shining Elevator Scene analysis

Ok, ok, I know, I already demonstrated my ability to derail a reading response with a tenuous analogy connecting the readings to a movie I've recently watched, but bear with me because this so totally relates to Eisner, Freedman, and Barrett...

As I read Eisner's reproduction of a student's response to the red dye creepily saturating a glass of water (p 60), I couldn't help but think of this scene from The Shining because the day prior I received reassurance that I wasn't the only Kubrick nut rattling on semi-coherently of late. Check out this article.

Now, being a proper fanboy, I was already aware that The Shining has been interpreted as a comment on the destruction of the Native American peoples. But since it's not one of my favorite readings of the film(PING Barrett: some interpretations are better than others), I doubt it would have came to mind if I hadn't just recently been reminded of it by this article. But far and away, my favorite thing about this article and the YouTube clip is that they provide more linguistic snd conceptual fodder for my thoughts on Kubricks's films because "the ability to transform qualities of experience into speech and text" (Eisner, p 86) is important and film, which includes a temporal element, is so nearly experiential that without those intermediaries the experience can slip away. Also, it's good to know that someone else out there is watching closely enough to have called out the Times article's author on his tuxedo/top hat mix up (see article correction) and to see that Lichanos' comment on the bottom echos the observation I made in my last post about the homicidal apes in 2001 (because that helps me as I seek to balance personal and communal interpretations; PING Barrett again).

All of this serves to reinforce the notion I already held that Kubrick's work serves as what we called in my days as a lit student a Rich Text. Rich texts are works that reward repeated readings/viewings; works that grow and change as we do. The reason I've got Kubrick on the brain right now is that I got his collected works on blu ray for Christmas. I already had them all on DVD since they were among the first DVDs I bought back in high school when I got my first DVD player and some of them I had on VHS before that, so I can testify to their quality in this respect, but I don't really need to since a wealth of literature has grown and continues to grow around them. Which is the only quantitative means of determining a rich text: how many other works exist that draw on or discuss the work in question. The Bible and Shakespeare are among the richest texts extant, but, as Barrett mentions in passing, volumes of work on Magritte were likely consulted and whittled down into the encyclopedia entry that he reprints, so Magritte's work constitutes a rich text as well.

But how does that happen? How does one text become richer than another? Freedman uses two Kubrick films as examples of the type of "popular films that have postmodern forms [and] are edited in a pastiche that focuses the audience on structure and process" (p 34) and that, I suspect, is one means by which a work achieves such status--by leaving ample room for interpretation. In this sense, it is partly the medium and its handling that creates the condition. For Shakespeare, it's not only the breadth of his vocabulary and the quantity of material he left behind, but that his works are plays and lean upon the reader or theater professional or film maker to complete them. The Bible's variety of cultures, time periods, authors and styles make it an extraordinarily malleable reference point for a variety of ideological and creative ends (though, I would argue, it's a bit of a mixed bag in therms of Richness).

I'm misusing Freedman a bit though because in that passage, she's actually suggesting that these films are an examples of a new phenomenon and the two examples I've just given are very old. But I think she's misusing Kubrick, so turnabout is fair play. Freedman asserts that "no audience in a postindustrial democracy can be considered visually naive" and makes use of Kubrick as evidence for that statement but of Kubrick's and the other films listed in those parentheses, I would count none--with the possible exception of Pulp Fiction--as solid examples of popular culture in a postindustrial democracy. The reality is that the most mainstream of films in our postindustrial culture still adhere quite faithfully to the machinations of the invisible narrator. Which is not to say that she does not have a point, just that she should have narrowed her argument: given the proliferation and dominance of visual information in our culture, audiences are only as naive as they would like to be--alternatives are available. What she touches on, though, in suggesting that these are "popular" films, is the other means by which a text becomes rich--popularity--and that popularity may have little to do with any inherent quality in the material, it's just that a bigger audience results in a bigger audience response. And that bigger audience can be as much from luck as anything else. One of my favorite examples of blind popularity enriching a text is the phenomenon of film/album synchronicity, as exemplified by the pairing of the films version of The Wizard of Oz and Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon (there's a whole culture of looking for such pairings on the Internet if you care to search for it). These are wholly unrelated works of art being used by their audiences to build new communal meanings.

What has really happened with visual culture over the past century is not that it has become more sophisticated, as Freedman suggests, but that it has become more popular. Any perceived increase in sophistication is likely a residual effect of that popularity. Freedman goes on to elaborate on the new need to reassess aesthetic study of visual culture because of this proliferation with reference to Theodore Adorno's "lament" at "the collapse of the boundaries between fine art and popular culture" and she later (p 41) brings Adorno back up as a contrast with Dewey's "neopragmatist" approach, at which point she works a bit of her own aesthetic magic by using what I believe is the only first-person singular pronoun in the entire chapter. "I have always been uncomfortable with the apparently elitist perspective of Adorno's aesthetic..." she confesses. This is in spite of the fact that the very first marginal note that I wrote in this chapter was right next to the very first sentence: "active-ist."

From her first sentence, it is clear that Freedman has an agenda; that she is making an argument.  Yet, her writing style has the peculiar habit of hiding her voice.  In other words, right up until the imaginary fourth wall is broken by her confessed discomfort, Freedman has been hiding the narrator.

Saturday, January 28, 2012

Bumper Sticker

Since I got stuck on an Eisner/Kubrick kick in my last post, I'll borrow my bumper sticker from Freedman:

"The new conditions of visual culture illustrate that personal freedoms no longer only involve matters of free speech. They concern freedom of information in a range of visual art forms integral to the creation of individual and group knowledge. People cannot only speak freely; they can visually access, display and duplicate, computer manipulate, and globally televise."

Power to the people!

(That said, I must admit I feely both sympathetic and weary as I read Freedman. I've written elsewhere on this blog about how "As a student of literature, I wound up getting pretty frustrated with the poststructuralist critical discourse: all that reading between the lines leads one to suspect equivocation everywhere." That was about an article by Duncum, but their perspectives seem pretty closely aligned.)

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

LTC 8740, Post 1: The Begetting Stone

“…even a stone can be attended to so that its aesthetic character can serve as a source of that special form of life we call art.”  (Eisner, p 10)


In chapter one, Eisner describes the nature and birth of learning.   With characteristic cynicism, Stanley Kubrick dramatized this same process in his film 2001: A Space Odyssey.  As Eisner tells us, “[the] ability to experience the qualitative world we inhabit is initially reflexive in character….But we also learn….to see, to hear, to discern the qualitative complexities of what we taste and touch” (p. 2).  In other words, what begins as instinct develops, through repetition and practice, into deliberation.  Deliberation becomes the basis for the formation of concepts.  Concepts, in turn, create and shape culture.   Through concepts “we can imagine possibilities we have not encountered, and we can….create, in the public sphere, the new possibilities we have imagined in the private precincts of our consciousness” (p. 3).  But all of it begins with and grows from experience and perception. 

                Eisner and Kubrick seem to be in agreement that this quality is unique to humans.  Kubrick depicts an imagined moment at which the leap from the animal to the human world is made, via the intervention of…  Well, of what, exactly?  The scenario presented in the film leads the viewer to believe it to be the intervention of some sort of alien intelligence, but Kubrick deliberately leaves this vague.  The monolith, which is later encountered again on the moon and in orbit around Jupiter, is the only evidence we have of an alien being in the film, so, like the characters who organize a mission to seek them out, we are forced to assume their presence.  But this is only a concept that we are applying to the scenario.  We are familiar with intelligence as a concept and we presume that we can spot its makings.  In (cinematic) reality, it is the ape’s encounter with an unprecedented experiential phenomenon that sparks its imaginative leap, and that is all.  For Kubrick, that imaginative leap leads, ironically, to new destructive possibilities--this YouTube clip has been edited to cut out a scene in which the bone-wielding ape and his tribe assault a neighboring tribe, and the satellite in orbit that occurs at the end of the clip was originally intended to be read as containing nuclear weapons—but it also leads to the kind of culture that produces a visionary like Kubrick and the shared experiences that his films create.  As Eisner has it, “imagination, fed by the sensory features of experience is expressed in the arts through the image,” which, in turn, allows us a qualitative, shared vision, that will—with any luck—“ refine our sensory system and [cultivate] our imaginative abilities” (p 4).

                But how does qualitative, visionary work like Kubrick’s get us, as a culture, past the urge to smash, bomb, and blast for personal gain?  Eisner describes that a little more fully near the end of chapter one.  First of all, the arts encourage us to slow down by rewarding effortful concentration.  Of this, Eisner says:

“In the context of practical activity, the criterion of efficiency matter a great deal.  Normally we try to see the world and act upon it with the least amount of energy that will satisfy the realization of our purposes.  Put another way, we typically see things in order to classify and use them.” (p 23)

This effect is also described in the ‘Make a Gap’ chapter of our Imagination First text.  In that chapter, the example of a cat that is observed from the opposite size of a picket fence is given: our minds fill in the gaps created by the fence and we perceive the cat without any conscious effort.  In the recent book by Nobel Prize winning psychologist, Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow, he refers to this effect as being the result of what he calls the “lazy controller.”  Kahneman describes how glucose stores are actually used up by effortful processing in the mind, and as a result, we’ve developed a variety of mental shortcuts that allow us to function without needing to suck down sugar 24 hours a day.  As a result, the more “expert” we become in a task, the more shortcuts we work out to help us continue with our work.  The arts “help students learn how to savor qualities by taking the time to really look so that they can see” (Eisner, p 24) and Kubrick’s  film, as with many works of art that came before it, presents an opportunity to reflect on our world, our actions, our motivations, and the possibilities present in all of those things. 

This reflection is important because slowing down and reflecting operates on the development of concepts, which in turn, influences culture and all of those that do and will take part in that culture.  “What is clear,” says Eisner, “is that culture depends upon these communications because communication patterns provide opportunities for members of a culture to grow” (p 7) and “….the child’s mind is shaped by the culture of which the foregoing conditions are a part” (p 22).  So, by delineating the destructive and dangerous sides of innovation and progress and juxtaposing them against their heroic and beautiful aspects, Kubrick may have done more than provide a cautionary tale or a bit of black humor—he may have forged a few new mental shortcuts to make it easier on the next generation of innovators and educators.


Post Script: On Experts
Our talk last week about experts and expertise versus the (dying?) ideal of a liberal education made me think of this song off of Laurie Anderson's last album which is catchy, funny, and spot on:


Thursday, December 8, 2011

One Quality of Inaction (visual metaphor for Speak)

Super Cool Person Making Stuff On The Internet

Alright, so here's an Art Ed resource that you probably won't find described that way anywhere else so pay attention! :-)

http://www.youtube.com/user/Vihart

This is Vi Hart's YouTube channel. I found her because I'm a compulsive reader of The New York Times and they did a profile on her a while back.  What's Super Cool is that she's not an Art Ed person and she doesn't even identify as a Visual Artist but she is a full-fledged Visual Thinker (among her many other Modes of Thought).  She's a Mathematician and a Musician and a Maker of Videos and if you're ever stumped for ways to cross-disciplinize some basic math ideas in an arty way, her videos just might be the seeds to get your arty ideas growing. (Not to mention being great examples of lo-fi, smart, engaging, internet-era video making.)

Art Ed Visual Metaphor Statement

I tried to let my Art Ed metaphor reflect my beliefs from the bottom up.  I’ve been experiencing a revival of my interest in film/video as an art form—partly, I think, as an outgrowth of my field assignment this semester where half of my time has been with a photography class.  It’s my belief that the best kind of art education provides a model of learning in which students are allowed to capitalize on their strengths and interests—to develop and grow by following their muse.  My muse was leading me toward learning a little about Adobe’s After Effects video editing software, so I took this assignment as an opportunity to follow it.  Further, my tastes often lead me toward neatly bundled conceptual packages, so I decided to use my “teacher”—the instructional video—as the material for my own creation.  This allowed for a layering of perceptual experiences with the first layer being the “on-screen” instruction and modeling being demonstrated by the source material (teacher) and the second layer being the “off-screen” learning being modeled by the source material’s manipulator (student: me).  I made an effort to exaggerate the techniques being described by the narrator and delayed and prolonged certain effects after the narrator had moved on so as to simulate the play between observation and experimentation as it occurs in the art classroom.