To do a thing artfully is to do it with attention or purpose that extends beyond the ordinary; to do a thing artfully is to do it with care. I believe that the role of art education in today’s public school curriculum is to provide students with a model for a type of excellence that cannot be achieved through test-taking strategies or rote memorization. The practice of the professional artist has always involved a keen awareness of the models and methods of art creation that have come before, often with an eye toward advancing the practices or aesthetics of his/her particular medium(s). But the methodology for achieving success as an artist or with a particular artwork has never been a strictly linear or, even, entirely logical operation. There are many, many paths to great artistic achievement and every great artist must ultimately find their own way. As art educators we must provide students with the groundwork on which to construct their individual paths; we must make efforts to familiarize them with models of excellence culled from art history and we must help them understand the tools through which that success was achieved. But because art cannot be defined as one type of activity, or even any grouping or list of activities, we must be ready to extend our practice beyond the precedents of art history and follow our students as they find the mediums to which they have decided to focus their care and attention.
Brain Imaging Center & Art Dept.
Wednesday, August 31, 2011
Wednesday, June 29, 2011
addendum: about poets and purification
I struggled to explain my interpretation of what Eliot felt about a poet’s role being the “purification” of the dialect of the tribe and how this applies to the evolution of visual culture this morning, so I wanted to take a second to try and explain it a little better here…
While the role of “purification” does not necessarily fall to poets alone—since writers of prose can be just as deliberate in their choice of word and sentence structure—the process of making those choices is all the more transparent in poetry because, generally speaking, there are altogether fewer words in a completed piece of poetry than in prose and because both the author and the audience are likely to be familiar with the traditional poetic structures available to the poet and the level of adherence/caprice being used in following or diverting from those structures. Over the course of the Four Quartets, Eliot slips into and out of various structures and deliberately quotes (or “appropriates”) past masters/masterworks, altering and juxtaposing them at his own discretion. It is the level of care that he takes in employing his poetic tools that allow him to show concern for the “dialect of the tribe.” He elaborates on the process at another point in the Quartets:
“…every phrase
And sentence that is right (where every word is at home,
Taking its place to support the others,
The word neither diffident nor ostentatious,
An easy commerce of the old and the new,
The common word exact without vulgarity,
The formal word precise but not pedantic,
The complete consort dancing together)…”
And sentence that is right (where every word is at home,
Taking its place to support the others,
The word neither diffident nor ostentatious,
An easy commerce of the old and the new,
The common word exact without vulgarity,
The formal word precise but not pedantic,
The complete consort dancing together)…”
Eliot always took great care to acknowledge the literary shoulders on which he stood (he wrote a very famous essay, Tradition and Individual Talent, about the relationship between the canon and its contemporary workers), so he saw this “purification” as a slowly evolving and deliberate process in which the self-aware poet did their best to chart a position in the course of literary affairs and choose the right words for their particular time and purpose.
Now, here’s how I see this applying to visual culture… Because of the way that technology and culture evolved, Eliot was in a better position to choose deliberately and understand his place at the end of that long chain than anyone working in the century preceding his own. The printing press had been in action since the 15th century but the early 20th century was probably the golden age of the printed word: newspapers wielded tremendous power, public libraries were ubiquitous, television was just a twinkling in some techie’s eye, and even radio broadcasting didn’t really get started until the 1920s (Elliot published The Waste Land in 1922). Written language, through its long course of evolution, had achieved a tremendous amount of agency. The masses were, by and large, literate and contributing to the written collective. This means that written culture had come a long, long way from the days when written culture was largely the domain of the lawmaking and priestly classes.
Which leads us to why this is a matter of “purification”… Another 20th century literary figure (and coincidentally, another St. Louis native—Eliot was born and raised there), William Burroughs, had a sort of sci-fi scenario/theory that language is a virus, that it arrived from the outer reaches of the universe and started to prey on human beings by taking control of their thoughts and actions. I think that may be taking it a bit far, but there may be some truth in it too: if language evolved to serve a need and if that need was, for a long period of time, exploited to reflect the ends of an elite ruling class, then it is reasonable to expect language to contain some vestiges of its evolution as a tool of oppression. At the very least, it probably took until the 20th century for the majority of a population of a nation to be encouraged to make use of writing as a tool for deliberate and reflective action. So, I believe that to “purify the dialect of the tribe” means to take a more perfect control of the tool of language—to do one’s part to wipe out the ostentatiousness, pedantry, and vulgarity—and to help everyone think just a little more keenly.
I believe that visual culture is now at or nearing the point at which Eliot encountered the written word. We must try to help our students see the Photoshoped models, the smartly seductive product placements, the ideologies of perpetual consumption and unhappiness, etc. clearly and we must try to help them see the alternatives clearly also. Visual culture is becoming a collective. As art educators we must help our students see the whole and plot their course.
Tuesday, June 28, 2011
when the going gets weird... (this I believe)*
We live in a time when rapid progress in technology is driving the habits and understanding of successive generations further apart at the same time that it is bringing the distant corners of the Earth closer together. As Howard Gardner points out, “We should, for sure, think globally, but we should, for equally strong reasons, act locally, nationally, and regionally” (Gardner, 2009, p 18). This puts educators in a sticky situation, with the duty to reach students who have been born into a whole new world while that world raps loudly and deservingly at the door to the classroom. As teachers we must develop habits of mind and methods of working that reflect a far-reaching and inclusive attitude toward culture and knowledge at the same time that we evolve pedagogy capable of keeping pace with the changing needs of our students.
I believe that we in the field of art education can lead the way into this exciting new educational landscape. As Douglas Thomas and John Seely Brown point out in their chapter ‘Knowing, Making, and Playing’, recent changes in technology and culture call for a new kind of literacy—one in which context is the locus of meaning (Thomas & Brown, 2011). Olivia Gude’s postmodern principles describe a variety of specific techniques used by artists that provide avenues of creation, play and communication through the manipulation of an object or symbol’s conceptual framework (Gude, 2004). The techniques she describes are not new, Gude has begun the task of recognizing and describing them, but professional art practice has arguably reflected the sensibility of contextually directed meaning for nearly a hundred years now. Art educators have the wealth of their discipline’s past century of work to draw from as they move to meet the needs of today’s students.
With our eyes toward the past century (and, indeed, the centuries and millennia before), I believe we must work toward what T.S. Eliot once referred to as a need “to purify the dialect of the tribe.” With advances in technology, visual culture, like written language before it, has moved from the hands of the elite to become a collective property. But all too often the dialogue is saturated with manipulation and the residual meanings of an antiquated power structure that is fighting to squeeze whatever it can from this apparatus before the reins are pulled completely away. As workers in the field of visual culture—as artists—our tribe is truly global. As educators our greatest responsibility is to reveal to the students that pass through our doors the rights and responsibilities that are attendant on their own membership. By studying visual culture and the works and methods of great artists, and by facilitating deliberate and reflective art making in the classroom, I hope I will be doing my part to empower my students and to help them become respectful and effective members of the global community.
Gardner, H. (2009). Five minds for the future. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
Gude, O. (2004). Postmodern principles: In search of a 21st century art education. Art Education, 57(1), 6-14.
Thomas, D, & Seely, J. (2011). A new culture of learning: cultivating the imagination for a world of constant change. Lexington, KY: Createspace.
*Bonus rant. I just can't stop synthesizing. This title is the first part of a quote from Hunter S. Thompson. The quote popped into my head as I began to write this statement at just about the same moment that I knew I needed to lead toward the T.S. Eliot quote. The two references together help explain my transition from a student of literary to artistic discourse and the original motives behind my desire to become an art educator. In my time as a student of the English department at MU, the term 'text' had already come to describe just about any phenomena that would bear close-reading and interpretation. Thus, images were a suitable subject for study and reference in the papers we wrote as students of English and I quickly spread my interests to Art History and used my understandings of each discourse as a buoy for the narratives and analyses I constructed there. But, as I wrote and wrote and wrote I began to become dissatisfied with this relatively passive approach to visual culture. To be an informed and critical consumer of visual culture is all well and good, but it is still only consumption. As advances in technology have moved the elements of visual design to an integral role in the production of nearly all media--written and otherwise--the time seemed ripe to broaden our understanding of Eliot's conception of literary tradition. The word is still vital and active but it is rarely encountered or considered au naturel anymore, nor does it need be: the visual idea is now as easily transmitted as the verbal (see my discussion of this shift in THEVERYMANY blog entry).
The idea that literacy now involves a simultaneous engagement with verbal and visual disciplines sometimes strikes me as an anachronistic novelty. It’s as though the high-piled evidence of 20th century culture has belatedly triggered recognition, one decade deep into the 21st century, that cultural artifacts have undergone a dramatic remodel. Perhaps this helps explain the muddled aspect of English/language arts pedagogy over the last quarter of the 20th century: film (the original multi-media recording format) was already generating a tremendous library but nobody was quite sure what to do with it and certainly some film directors deliberately shifted their productive efforts from literature over to the new medium. Pier Paolo Pasolini provides one of the most dramatic examples, describing his transition from writing to film as “an explosion of my love for reality.” In retrospect, Pasolini looks like a secular prophet. His statement reflects a fundamental shift in the dynamics of authorship that occurred with the advent of film: if the author’s act of recording was motivated by a particular love of or engagement with the phenomena of life, why struggle with the intermediary any longer? A more perfect medium had been invented.
But, of course, that interpretation is a bit naïve. There are difficulties wrapped up with the medium of film as well. Reality is immersive; film can only capture targeted aspects of that immersion. And in some respects, the shortcomings of film edified the functional shorthand of language, just as the shortcomings of photography fortified the expressive qualities of painting. Regardless, the manner of knowing and understanding life had changed dramatically and irrevocably. Now, in the medium of hypertext, the choices to be made about how best to represent one aspect of reality or another is no longer a matter of choosing the best word only, but of choosing the best format as well. This is what is now required to “purify the dialect” and to do it we must study, experiment, and play, in the variety of formats available and we must teach our students to do it too.
Gardner suggests that it takes ten years to achieve mastery of a discipline and I’m sure that he has a mound of theory and research to back that up (see http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/opinion/sunday/26ideas.html for a recent, interesting discussion of the shortcomings of science), so the code-switching I suggest may seem daunting, but I’m not at all convinced that a standard for mastery is justifiable or necessary. And even if it is, when one stops to consider the rapid exponential improvements in technology that lie at the heart of our changing culture, do the time frames studied really apply anymore? It seems unlikely.
We live in weird times and when the going gets weird, the weird turn pro. Who knows? Maybe in the next five years art will become the discipline that leads policy and pedagogical discussion. Stranger things have happened.
(And just one more little aside: if you’ve never read T.S. Eliot’s Four Quartets, I strongly, strongly, oh so strongly recommend it: http://www.tristan.icom43.net/quartets/ My quote comes from the Fourth Quartet when Eliot encounters the ghost of a poet that could be any--even his own. The Quartets are sequential, with references that build on each other, so reading the whole thing helps it make better sense than the lone segment, but it’s strong meat and you can probably pick and choose profitably too [although Joni Mitchell resigned from the task of whittling them down for a composition by Charles Mingus, saying that it was like trying to cut verses from the Bible])
Friday, June 17, 2011
paper proposal
I’ve recently become very interested in ancient Egyptian art. I admire the way that their artworks—or, at least, what we know of them—blend seamlessly into their culture. The Egyptians did not have a word that serves as an equivalent for ‘art’. The Egyptians did not make works of art, but they put great effort into making things artfully. Their priest class was closely related to their class of scribes and it is difficult to distinguish too finely between their scribes and a grouping of people that we might in our parlance deem ‘artists’. Indeed, many of the strategies employed for the composition of paintings, architecture, and statuary are derived from the hieroglyphic writing system that also serves as an integral part of these works.
Alongside the admiration that I feel for the holistic achievements of Egyptian culture is an awareness of the subversive side of this integration. The Egyptian art that we study today was almost exclusively created to serve the ends of the ruling class and was almost certainly a source of oppression for the classes of society that served them. Literacy was reserved to members of the royalty, political functionaries, the class of priests, and the scribes, and the cultural remains that survive attest to the disproportionate share of resources that these classes enjoyed. For the rest of Egyptian society, the impact of the hieroglyphs and their transparent integration with all aspects of civil engineering amounted to a constant reminder of their subservient and largely invisible role in society.
In my paper, I am interested in exploring the history of art education in the United States to uncover examples of figures, schools, and movements that have acknowledged the presence of social inequality in visual culture and the efforts that they have made to work against those inequities. Even in our culture, fine art has generally been a pastime for the wealthy, subject to their patronage, and reflecting their interests. In the early 20th century, a variety of efforts were made to address the power struggle inherited by students of the discipline. In his work with the Barnes Foundation, John Dewey sought to reunite the accepted cannon of fine artwork with decorative and folk works. Margaret Naumberg and Florence Cane sidestepped the issue outright by excluding previously made artworks from the classroom and encouraging expression over craft. In my paper, I hope to discover the range of responses to this issue and chart its course from the beginning of the 20th century up to contemporary practices.
Thursday, June 16, 2011
Thursday, June 9, 2011
THEVERYMANY
There was much of interest and much that rang true in the “Developing a Repertoire of Skills for Visual Perception and Artistic Response” chapter. Many of the suggestions in the first three sections dovetailed nicely with the VTS work we’ve been doing with the Boy Writers over at Ridgeway. Also, I’ve still not shaken the frustration I repeatedly experienced as I observed a field teacher (during an earlier placement) consistently send her students imaginatively cold into the work of art creation. I particularly liked this statement from the ‘Practice’ section of the first section: “When a full and rich image has developed in the imagination, work can begin to bring the image into visual form.” The distinction between active imagination and active creation is too often overlooked.
However, my curiosity was most piqued by the mention of an article that challenged that challenged traditional design terminology as being insufficient or outmoded by the advent of computer graphic technologies. And the article was written in 1996. 1996! That was way before Photoshop became a verb (though still a whopping eight years after the development of Photoshop 1.0). So, I looked it up…
And almost everything it had to say is still valid. If anything, I had to stop and wonder whether we’ve already inadvertently bent some of the old terminology to cover our new understanding of pictorial space. It may be that I can’t step far enough outside of my contemporary box to say which terms have already evolved and I kind of suspect that’s one factor that made this such a dense and difficult read. I had to stop regularly and try to remember whether there was a slightly different nuance to words like space, shape, and texture before navigating digital displays became a daily occurrence. But it’s also that the author is dealing with some pretty abstract concepts—things that either fly under the radar of our daily activities or that we’re still coming to terms with.
Here, for example, is the first disparity identified (out of a total of 20):
“In the literature of art education, the traditional formal image was viewed as a whole, with stable, analog contents bound to the form. Computer graphics were determined to be dynamic and digital, and procedures were determined to play an important part in expanding the idea of an abstract "language." Generative and interpolative procedures in computer graphics, as well as the replicability of the same image in different output modes, beg notions of what is original or unique in art. Signifiers that are appropriated (see Gombrich, 1961, for a discussion of codes and signifiers) also appear to be an important part of artistic language in both mediums. The implications are that, even in terms of its visual properties, the formal image can no longer be perceived as referring only to itself with what has been described as "permanent or residual aesthetic value" (Crozier & Greenhalgh, 1992, p. 83-4).”
Wooza, that’s a lot to digest. On first read, I latched on to “replicability” begging “notions of what is original or unique in art” and it led me to think of Gude’s Postmodern Appropriation Principle. But after a second (and third) read I think it may go deeper than that. It may help to refer back to that magnificent distinction that I pointed out earlier, the one between active imagination and active creation. Take, for example, Picasso’s Les Demoiselles d'Avignon. We think of this painting as an object—a painting—because that is the corporeal form by which the image is conveyed. Now, if Picasso had designed the image on a computer, then it would have no corporeal form—its dimensions would be relative, palette, saturation, brightness, etc would be variable. The work of imagination that brought it into being would still belong firmly to Picasso, but the creative product is harder to pin down, involving an interaction between the creator, the end-user, and the technology in-between. The reality is that this has been the case for a very long time. I’ve never actually seen Les Demoiselles in person. I’ve seen slides, posters, etc. recreating it, so I’m familiar with it—which means that I’m familiar with Picasso’s visual idea, but realistically, I’ve never actually seen the created product of that imagined idea. As such, any evaluations I might make of it cannot be wholly considered valid until I’ve seen the real thing. (And, of course, this is the reason that many people claim to hate various modern and contemporary works until they see them in person: I would never ever buy a book of reproductions of Rothko’s paintings, but I’d love to own one. Same goes for Donald Judd and most Op Art.) However, once I’ve seen the corporeal Les Demoiselles, I may finally rest my opinion or understanding of it amongst all those who have seen it since Picasso laid down the final brushstroke. With digital artwork, there is no comparable end-point for knowing a work. It may be that by the standards of traditional artwork, digital artwork is never actually complete. It never reaches a definitive, perfected state. That’s quite the change.
Another big change is the notion of three-dimensionality. In computer design terms, the creation of three-dimensional shapes is both less of an illusion than in the traditional two-dimensional formats and the codification of an illusion. Ironically, even though the illusion of three-dimensionality in computer graphics is created by a complete description of a three-dimensional object (along all three axis of dimension) as opposed to the selective recording and hiding of information (as happens in the rendering of three dimensional illusions on a traditional flat drawing surface, i.e. the illusion of foreshortened objects in drawings or paintings), rarely does that complete three-dimensional description achieve realization in the third dimension (you know, the palpable, real dimension that we go about our daily business in).
Here’s one of the exceptions. This is THEVERYMANY by Marc Fornes from 2010. I came across it on the contemporary floor of the Pompidou and aside from its obvious eye-catching qualities, something else about it that caught my attention: the museum label said that it was designed in Rhino 3D. That brought back some memories. Rhino 3D was the very first 3d design software that I ever used—and that was way back in 1996! Ha!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




